astrid dot tech

Things cis people often say when talking to trans people1

archived here from original thread, and expanded upon. literally none of these are hyperbolic at all, i have personally witnessed every single one of these points being argued for.

  • “you’re nearsighted? oh wow, have you gotten the surgery yet?”
  • “idk, are you really nearsighted? you don’t act nearsighted to me”
  • “okay so you say you ‘feel’ like everything is blurry. what does that mean? ive sometimes gotten dust in my eyes but i don’t see how you can just ‘feel’ nearsighted”
  • “ugh… why are you ruining your beautiful face with those glasses? you look fine without them”
  • “ugh… why are you ruining your eyes with those contacts? you’re ruining your eyes by putting them there”
  • “ugh… i can’t believe anyone would mutilate their beautiful, natural, working eyes by burning them with lasers just because they ‘feel’ nearsighted. medicine and liberalism has gone too far”
  • “can’t you just like, not see things blurry? it’s probably just that you’re not focusing your eyes correctly”
  • “noooo don’t put glasses on ur so handsome”
  • “humans didn’t have glasses, contacts, or laser surgery to transition to sightedness for millenia. therefore it’s all unnatural and bad”
  • “oh, you don’t want to get the surgery? you’re not truly nearsighted then lol”
  • “nearsightedness and farsightedness are just a way for millenials to feel special by adding labels onto themselves”
  • “optometry is a fake science invented by (((them))) to weaken the white race”
  • “sorry, your insurance doesn’t cover optometry, so you’ll have to pay for it out-of-pocket”
  • “they’re doing laser surgery on 6-year-olds who think their eyes are blurry!”
  • “if you wish to see 20/20 unassisted then why don’t you just wait until you die and reincarnate as a fully-sighted person?”
  • “i have blurry vision and i just deal with it lol”
  • “ugh, i can accept nearsighted and farsighted people, but ‘astigmatism’? you’re just inventing new diagnoses to explain why you need your little ‘accomodations’”

Contributed by others

  • 0x10f at tech.lgbt: “All your friends wear glasses too. Must be peer pressure.”
  • 0x10f at tech.lgbt: “Autistic people are more likely to identify as nearsighted, so they must be denied glasses.”
  • sabik at rants.au: “What if you regret lasering your eyes?”2
  • fabi at blahaj.zone: “By being nearsighted, you are limiting my personal freedom to not be nearsighted!”
  • fabi at blahaj.zone: “Do I have to wear glasses now as well?”
  • aemstuz at pol.social: “you’re just wearing glasses because it’s trendy to wear them! this has consequences on your eyes!”
  • dym at dym.sh: “stop telling kids some eyes are different and need additional support above the «[x] has eyes»”
  • dym at dym.sh: “i dont need your bad eyes in my gene pool”
  • dym at dym.sh: “if your eyes not perfect, do you even need them? way too much hassle to deal with imperfection”
  • dym at dym.sh: “yeah, my grandma had bad eyes and instead of complaining she always inviting other grandmas to her bookclub to just read to each other aloud — and sometimes they didnt even need books!”
  • transbutterflyqueen at woem.men: “just squint! lots of people have blurry vision, and you don’t see them wearing glasses.”
  1. this also applies to neurodivergent, depressed, and of course, nearsighted people, among others. these arguments have also been made by trans people against other trans people, too.

  2. LASIK regret is 4.6% (N = 2198),3 and trans surgery regret is 1% (N = 7928).4

  3. LASIK World Literature Review: Quality of Life and Patient Satisfaction (2009) doi:10.1016/j.ophtha.2008.12.037

  4. Regret after Gender-affirmation Surgery: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Prevalence (2021) doi:10.1097/GOX.0000000000003477